Roth vs. Traditional - Which is Better? with Sean Mullaney

Roth vs. Traditional - Which is Better? with Sean Mullaney

podcast strengthen - magnetic offer Feb 07, 2024

Are you a business owner navigating the world of retirement planning and feeling overwhelmed by the various options available? In a recent episode of the "Keep What You Earn" podcast, Shannon continued the conversation with Sean Mullaney, a financial planner and the author of the Fi Tax Guy blog. The pair delved deep into the debate surrounding Roth versus traditional retirement accounts and shed light on the often misunderstood intricacies of wealth management and retirement planning. Here, we will further explore the insights shared by Sean and Shannon to help you make informed decisions regarding your retirement savings.

The Traditional Retirement Account: Building Wealth through Tax Deductions

Sean started off by providing a clear distinction between traditional and Roth retirement accounts. The traditional model revolves around the concept of receiving a tax deduction on contributions made to the account, thus providing an immediate benefit in the form of tax savings. This approach incentivizes individuals to save for the future by offering an initial tax break, allowing the contributed amount to grow tax-deferred until withdrawal. However, the catch lies in the fact that withdrawals from traditional accounts are subject to taxation at ordinary income rates, offering tax deferral benefits during the accumulation phase.

The Roth Retirement Account: Tax-Free Growth and Withdrawals

In contrast, the Roth retirement account operates on a different principle. It involves making contributions after taxes, meaning no immediate tax deductions are provided. However, the contributed amount grows tax-free, and the withdrawals, upon meeting certain conditions, are disbursed tax-free as well. This presents an appealing prospect for individuals seeking to enjoy their retirement without the burden of facing a tax bill on their accumulated funds.

The Great Roth vs. Traditional Debate: Evaluating Key Considerations

Sean addressed the prevailing dialogue within the marketplace regarding the Roth versus traditional debate. He shared his perspective on why the traditional model might be more beneficial for most Americans, contrary to the popular narrative that heavily favors the Roth approach. Challenging the notion that retirees would face significantly higher tax liabilities in the future due to government debt, Sean emphasized the importance of understanding how retirees are actually taxed in retirement and the impact of deductible contributions.

Mixing and Matching Retirement Strategies: The Dynamic Duo Planning

Shannon and Sean delved into the concept of mixing retirement strategies, emphasizing the importance of understanding that it's not necessarily an all-or-nothing choice. They highlighted the opportunity to leverage both traditional and Roth accounts to optimize tax benefits, especially in situations where one qualifies for deductions at work but not for traditional IRA contributions at home. Sean coined the term "dynamic duo planning," encouraging individuals to consider a strategic blend of traditional and Roth accounts to maximize their tax advantages while diversifying their retirement savings.

The Savvy Approach: Retirement Account Diversification and Investment Strategies

Amidst the growing sentiment advocating non-traditional investment avenues and a shift away from retirement accounts, Sean presented a compelling argument for embracing retirement accounts, particularly traditional accounts, alongside other investment channels. He stressed the importance of diversification and leveraging the broader market to mitigate concentration risk, echoing the sentiment that avoiding over-reliance on specific income sources and investments is vital for long-term financial stability.

Wrapping Up: Empowering Business Owners in Retirement Planning

As the episode drew to a close, Sean left the audience with a resounding message: do not fear retirement contributions, particularly those directed towards traditional retirement accounts. His insights, coupled with Shannon's thought-provoking questions, served as a guiding light for business owners seeking to navigate the complex landscape of retirement planning.

In conclusion, the Roth versus traditional retirement account debate is nuanced, and there's no one-size-fits-all solution. Rather than succumbing to reactionary behavior based on generic advice or succumbing to the fear of making the wrong choice, business owners are encouraged to approach retirement planning with a clearer understanding of their individual circumstances and long-term financial goals. By leveraging a diversified approach to retirement savings and understanding the tax implications associated with traditional and Roth accounts, business owners can empower themselves to make sound decisions that align with their unique financial journeys.

By synthesizing Sean and Shannon's insights, business owners can gain a deeper understanding of the factors to consider when evaluating the best retirement account approach for their specific needs. The podcast episode serves as a valuable resource for business owners embarking on their retirement planning journey, equipping them with the knowledge and confidence to make informed decisions that set the stage for a financially secure future.

In the journey towards wealth building and financial freedom, the debate between Roth and traditional retirement accounts provides a spectrum of opportunities, and with the right knowledge, business owners have the power to navigate this terrain with clarity and conviction.

What you'll hear in this episode:

04:11 Concern over $34 trillion government debt grows.
06:29 Retirement tax rates favor upfront deductions.
10:11 Traditional vs. Roth, retirement dates and conversions.
14:42 Traditional 401k offers low effective tax rate.
18:12 Predictable fees, controlling for known investment costs.
21:47 "Trust market, diversify investments for personal finance.

If you like this episode, check out:

How to Build Trust with Your Customers

Why Just Bumping Up Prices Doesn't Cut It

How to Maximize the Return on an Unpaid Opportunity


Want to learn more so you can earn more?

Tax Deduction Guide:

Visit to dive deeper on our episodes

Visit to work with Shannon and her team

Watch this episode and more here:

Connect with Shannon on IG:


The information contained in this podcast is intended for educational purposes only and is not individual tax advice. Please consult a qualified professional before implementing anything you learn.